The Story of Cragen Beca

Cragen Beca is a Queen Conch shell (Lombatus gigas) which originates from the Caribbean sea and tropical northwestern Atlantic, from Bermuda to Brazil.

The shell has had the tip removed so that it can be used as a horn. It is alleged that it was blown to muster the Rebeccaites of Talog during the Rebecca Riots (1839 – 44) at the height of the disturbances.

Carmarthenshire was at the heart of the Rebecca Riots in which predominantly farmers and farm labourers rose against the authorities of the day. A campaign of protest saw them smash toll gates across the region in response to what was seen as unfair taxation amongst other hardships imposed at a time of great deprivation in the region.

Famously, the rioters usually dressed as women when they undertook their night time escapades, with their daring leader, named as Rebecca, leading the throng.

Cragen Beca was given to Carmarthenshire Museum in the 1980s and this account of the shell was part of the accession documentation.

Cragen Beca – A brief account

When I was a child “Cragen Beca” was kept under lock and key in a small wooden cabinet, hidden away behind a settee in my grandmother’s parlour in Talog. Her home had once been the “Castle Inn” public house, where her father and grandfather had been inn-keepers and which she inherited in due course.

During the Rebecca Risings (1839-46) this conch shell (Cragen Beca) had been given to the inn-keeper, who was my great great grandfather, and was used by him to muster the rioters to clandestine meetings etc. He was the official ‘whipper-up”. His involvement in the Riots was therefore most significant and put him in great civil danger. When the Rebecca Riots ceased there was a general round-up of all who were connected with the risings. Many were apprehended, some were imprisoned, others were transported, and many Talog men went into hiding in farm lofts and even in the woods which surrounded the village. It is obvious that the inn-keeper had kept a very low profile throughout because he was not even suspected!

No wonder then, that the Cragen was so carefully hidden – for a whole century its secrets were so closely kept that my mamgu would only show it on rare occasions, and even spoke about it in whispers! Only once did I ever hear it being blown in public, and that was without her knowledge. The occasion was the success of a Liberal candidate in a parliamentary election. My uncle had taken the conch from its hiding place and trumpeted his joy from the hilltop, for which indiscretion and indiscipline he was verbally and physically chastised by his mother!

And now to the origin of Cragen Beca. Most historians would agree that the organising genius behind the Rebecca Riots in west Wales was a Carmarthen solicitor, Mr. Hugh Williams, a native of Machynlleth who had married a St Clears lady, practiced law in Carmarthen but resided in Cydweli. It is accepted that he had radical tendencies and was sympathetic to the Chartists. The Rebecca Rioters themselves were mostly farmers and farmworkers, most of whom were illiterate and quite unable to organise such a covert, but highly disciplined crusade. It required an astute, intelligent brain to bring scattered communities of highly charged farmers together into a viable force, and who better than the pragmatic lawyer from Carmarthen?

It transpires that Hugh Williams had a brother serving either as a consul or else a Civil Servant in Sierra Leone, and that he was stationed in Freetown, originally founded as Granville in 1788 as a home for liberated African slaves. These had come from the Caribbean islands and from the mainland of America.

During the 1939 – 45 war I served in the Royal Navy, and during one of my visits to Freetown I witnessed a native funeral. Proceeding the cortege was a man who blew a conch shell, the sound being directed towards the sea. The sound was unmistakable, it was the same reverberating “hoot” that I had heard in Talog years previously! We spoke to this man who explained that it was traditional to inform the spirits who dwelt in the sea whenever a fisherman’s soul was returning to his final resting place. I was immediately reminded of the god Triton in Greek mythology who ruled the waves by blowing his conch.

Is it too improbable to assume that Hugh Williams was given the conch, that became “Cragen Beca”, by his brother, and that he in turn gave it to the inn-keeper of Castle Inn Talog to be used by the “whipper-up” to summon the rioters?

(And since the conch is not indigenous to West Africa, is it beyond the bounds of possibility that it was brought to Sierra Leone by one of the liberated slaves? *)

*This is supposition, of course.

This account weaves a rich narrative of intrigue and subversion around Cragen Beca. It goes on to speculate about its possible origins, but we will probably never know exactly how it found its way to a village pub in the hills of Carmarthenshire.

More recent research has cast some doubt on the nature of solicitor Hugh Williams’ involvement with the Rebeccaites (including the speculation that he may even have been Rebecca herself), although he certainly championed their cause and represented many of the rioters, including those from Talog, in law.

The assertion that the farmers and farmworkers of the region were not able to organise their own actions during the Rebecca risings has also been challenged by recent scholars. This doesn’t, of course, negate the possibility of the shell arriving into west Wales via Williams’ family connections.

Hugh Williams’ brother, William Williams was actually a sailor, it is believed that he was recruited into the Brazilian Navy under the alias Joao (John) Williams as a mercenary. He served for five years from 1823 to 1828 under an initiative to recruit Ex-British Naval officers, men and volunteers as part of the Brazilian War of Independence from Portugal. Recruited in London, he initially served as a volunteer under the maverick ex-Admiral of the British Navy, Admiral Thomas Cochrane on his flagship Pedro Premeiro during the blockade of Bahia. There he served alongside British and North American sailors as well as black marines recently emancipated from slavery. Following Brazil’s independence, he continued to serve on warships as sub-lieutenant and lieutenant, fighting against Argentina in the Cisplatine Wars. There is, however, no mention of his presence in Freetown, Sierra Leone.

Perhaps he spent time in this British Crown Colony at the end of his contract before returning to Wales, where it is presumed he came to live with his brother Hugh.

The posting would not necessarily have been a fortuitous one: “The loss of colonial officials and administrators was so common that the surviving officials had to hold numerous posts at the same time, while they awaited new arrivals from Britain. Of all the British colonies to which a sailor or colonial administrator could be dispatched, Sierra Leone, in the 1820s, remained the one with the highest rate of death by disease.” [1] Did William arrive back in Carmarthenshire already weakened by a tropical disease such as Malaria? Did he bring with him a trunk full of souvenirs from his travels? Perhaps even a Queen Conch trumpet used as a navy signaling horn or acquired amongst the prizes of war?

William Williams died in 1832 aged 37, his body was taken in a waterborne procession down the river Tywi for burial at the church of St Ishmael’s. Revd Thomas Jenkins (father of the well-known Carmarthenshire diarist Thomas Jenkins and friend of Hugh Williams) wrote the poem The Sailor’s Grave in his honour. It is tempting to imagine the Cragen being blown to guide his soul seawards on his final journey along the Tywi estuary. The subtext of his death notice in The Cambrian [2] paints William as something of an adventurer and a rogue. The genteel civil servant pen-pushing in a town founded upon emancipation suggested in the museum’s Cragen Beca documentation seems rather less plausible. Instead we find an ambitious mercenary in the navy of a country whose slave trading was at its height in the 1820s. It appears, however, that Williams’ own service was limited to skirmishing with the Portuguese and Argentinian navies. His brother Hugh shares his grave.

We can find clear evidence of Cragen Beca being blown in Talog in 1910.

An article in The Welshman confirms the use of the ‘historic horn of Rebecca Riots fame’ [3] to herald a visit by Liberal politician and staunch Welsh Nationalist John Hinds to Talog as part of his election campaign in 1910. Mr Hinds’ “…telling speech…delivered with great earnestness…” at Bethania Chapel which “…greatly denounced the power of the Lords…” [3] presumably referred to the Welsh Disestablishment Bill read in the Lords in 1909 which was smothered by other pressing concerns of that time. This bill referred to the disestablishment of non-conformists in Wales from the Anglican Church. The issue had a far deeper meaning for the people of Talog listening that day however “…Welsh disestablishment was also an issue about the recognition of Welsh identity…” [4], it was part of the long struggle for devolution in Wales.

Hinds’ obituary in The Welshman (3rd August 1928) spoke of ‘the esteem in which he was held by people of all sects and creeds, high and low, rich and poor, in every walk of life… a man who had been their true friend, and whose beautiful character (typified by his honesty, sincerity and simplicity) had won for him a warm place in their hearts’. [5] He also served as Lord Lieutenant of Carmarthenshire and Mayor of Carmarthen, gifting Parc Hinds to the town in 1927.

It is interesting to note that about 70 years previously, Bethania Chapel had hosted another passionate orator during the period of the Rebecca Riots. The Narrative of the Adventures and Escape of Moses Roper from American Slavery, was published in 1837 and recounted the story of the black American slave survivor Moses Roper who toured internationally to recount his tale in support of abolition. By 1841 the account had been translated into Welsh and by 1844 up to 5,000 copies had been sold. Moses visited many small chapels and halls throughout Wales including Bethania Chapel in Talog. Although we do not know the exact date of his visit, it is fascinating to consider how his account may have been received in the village at a time of such active social and political foment.

So, Talog can perhaps be seen as a crucible of rebellion and dissent and it is a fair assumption that Cragen Beca played a role in fomenting that energy and spirit in this part of the county. It is stirring to imagine that rallying note sounding out across the hills of the high back country of Carmarthen, calling its disaffected to action.

The little Carmarthenshire village of Talog has a pivotal role to play in the Rebecca Riots narrative. At the height of the disturbances in May and June 1843, Carmarthen’s Water Street toll gate on the old Newcastle road into the town was already a bone of contention and had been broken. Rebecca had threatened that whilst it was down no one was to pay the toll on pain of retribution. Three active Rebeccaites from Talog (whom it is alleged were present at the gate’s most recent demise) were fined for non-payment of the toll. John Harries of Talog Mill, Thomas Thomas, Talog Shopkeeper and Farm Servant, Samuel Bowen of Brynchwyth.

A detachment of four constables from Carmarthen were sent by foot to Talog to execute distress warrants following non-payment. Rebecca’s scouts were abroad and news of their approach was broadcast. Accounts speak of a bugler in white blowing a horn, possibly Cragen Beca, and the constables being intercepted at Blaenycoed by disguised Rebeccaites, here they were turned back to Carmarthen. A band of Rebeccaites from nearby Abernant then went on to destroy woodland and part of a newly erected ornamental wall on the property of local magistrate David Davies of Trawsmawr who had endorsed the issuing of the warrant.

Outraged and embarrassed by this flagrant disorder, officials sent a further detachment to Talog a couple of days later. This time 12 constables and specials and 28 unarmed army pensioners were sent on foot to issue the warrants. Arriving at Talog Mill, they seized property from John Harries, but by this time the bugler had once again roused the neighborhood and around 300 disguised men had been mustered. Thomas Thomas now convinced the Carmarthen contingent to return Harries’ goods with a promise to pay his fine, having already paid his own. At this point Rebecca took control and after a short, sharp battle forced the constables and specials to discharge their weapons and surrender their ammunition and pistols. They were then marched to Trawsmawr once again, the warrant was ceremoniously shredded and the constables were forced to finish the work that had been started demolishing the ornamental wall of David Davies. The army pensioners were politely dismissed back to town by Rebecca with respectful words for their long service to the country. A short while afterwards the constables were sent packing after them with bullets whistling over their heads.

The following few days saw furious activity with Rebeccaite meetings being called across the area, support being rallied with the usual menaces, and funds being collected. Meanwhile in Carmarthen the fury of the authorities mounted and military support was sent by the Secretary of State. A large-scale march was now being planned to present Rebecca’s grievances to the magistrates in Carmarthen and demand restoration of the payments taken from the Talog men. On Monday 19 June 1843 at 11am at least 300 mounted Rebeccaites,1,500 supporters on foot, including women and children and a band of hired musicians met at the Plough and Harrow inn, a few miles north of Carmarthen. Rebecca alone was in disguise, resplendent in a golden ringleted wig and mounted on a white horse.

Arriving in Carmarthen, the Rebeccaites met with a further band from St Clears before processing around the town with their musicians and protest banners. They had then intended to proceed to Guildhall square to meet with officials and hand over their demands for justice against a wide range of complaints. Before this could happen, and there are a number of suggested reasons for the following actions, a section of the crowd rerouted and headed for the Carmarthen workhouse where they gained entry and in high spirits (one woman allegedly dancing on the tables) began to demolish the premises. At that exact moment 29 men of the 4th Light Dragoons galloped onto the scene under the command of Major Parlby having just arrived from Cardiff via Pontarddulais. A chaotic scene ensued which saw Rebecca and her entourage routed, they either fled or found themselves under arrest.

Although this momentous day ended ostensibly in defeat for Rebecca, the audacity of events meant that news swiftly reached the government in London, Queen Victoria and The Times newspaper. Through a period of insightful news and other reports, which found largely in favour of Rebecca’s complaints, a process of enquiry ensued, which most notably precipitated reform of the hated Turnpike Trusts and tolls. Current thinking sees the issues of oppression and exploitation of the poor of Carmarthenshire by the upper classes and their officials as far more wide reaching and complex than the single issue of road tolls. In some ways this showcase reform could be seen as a convenient way for the government of the day to gloss over many of the other urgent needs of the population at this time. However, the spiritual victory of the people and their extraordinary leader has remained in the national imagination of the Welsh people ever since.

Further research into Cragen Beca’s possible origins and journey to Talog might suggest some alternative or complementary ideas to its presence in the village.

The Art Journal from 1874 [6] (rather later than the Rebecca Riots period) has a chapter on the use of shells in the arts and notes that 300,000 Queen Conch shells were imported into Liverpool in one year mostly for use in porcelain production.  It is possible that the shell could have made its way to the potteries of Llanelli or Swansea and from there, west to Talog.

It is interesting to note that Cragen Beca has had the distinctive flared outer lip of the Queen Conch removed. This is not a necessary procedure for the blowing of the shell and has historically been associated with the cameo carving industry in Italy in the 18th and 19th C (sometimes also France and London – but predominantly Italy). The lip only would have been taken for carving and the body of the shell was essentially waste. There do not appear to be any links which might link west Wales to this particular industry. The removal of the lip does however appear to be deliberate.

A news story in June 2020 reported a boat intercepted by the UK Border Force Maritime Command heading to the Welsh coast. Following a search of the vessel at Pembroke Dock, 7.5kgs of conch shells and coral (which require specialised import permits) amongst other banned and endangered sea animals and weaponry were discovered. A man, from Wales, was duly arrested. David Smith from Border Force said, “Wildlife trafficking groups use the same routes as criminals engaged in other forms of smuggling, including drugs and firearms…”. [7]. Smuggling as well as piracy and wrecking were also rife along the coastlines of west Wales between the 16th – 19th Centuries and who is to say that Cragen Beca didn’t arrive aboard a smuggler’s cutter or stashed amongst the contraband in the inlets and coves of Pembrokeshire, Carmarthenshire and Ceredigion?

Conch horns have been recorded as being used in Cornwall and coastal regions as foghorns. They were also to be found in north Wales relatively frequently, used on the farms to call in the cattle or the farm workers, maybe these shells made their way into the north Wales countryside from Liverpool. Perhaps Cragen Beca made its way south west from there – traded or bought at a farmers’ market or gifted through family connections. The shell has a worn patina that suggests much handling over the years, it could possibly have been on a farm for some generations serving that kind of function.

It is important to note here that this kind of shell trumpet would also have been used on slave plantations in the Caribbean and other colonies of the Americas.

It is quite possible that Cragen Beca found its way to Wales via slave trading routes; whether via direct trade or through established lines into Liverpool or Bristol.

There were direct commercial connections between Wales and the Atlantic slave trade. From the mid 17th C to 1830s cloth called ‘Welsh Plains’ was sent to clothe slaves working on the plantations (although it is hard to imagine a less suitable material for the climate). It was generally sourced from mid Wales, Montgomeryshire and Merionethshire, near to the English border. The wool was usually from Shropshire sheep but was fulled in the Welsh Mills.

The immensely profitable copper industry pioneered in Wales was also deeply implicated in the slave economy from the 17th C right through to the 1850s. The port of Swansea saw both the exportation of especially processed copper for slave trading in Africa in the 17th C and the exclusive importation of copper ore from the El Cobre mines of Cuba in the 19th C. The latter using Cuban owned slaves well beyond the British Slavery Abolition Act of 1833 and even The Act for the more effectual Suppression of the Slave Trade of 1843.

We also know that the origins of Rebeccaism lead clearly back to the custom of the Ceffyl Pren (Wooden Horse) in Wales. A practice which would certainly have been a feature of life in Carmarthenshire up until the mid-19th century.

This nighttime spectacle was a form of community justice administered by a jury and foreman in which the ritual humiliation of a perceived wrong doer was enacted. Often this involved tying the protagonist to a wooden frame and parading them around the houses to the accompaniment of ‘rough music’. The jury and foreman who performed the ritual usually wore blackened faces and the men often wore women’s clothing. Imaginatively, perhaps Cragen Beca could even have had a role here too, part of the cacophony that attended the drama.

The conch shell horn has been used by cultures across the world for music and festivities, for signaling at sea and on land, and for ritualistic, cult and religious purposes. It is freely available to collect from the seashore where large enough varieties thrive, easy enough to transform into an instrument, and its sound is distinctive and resonant. The Queen Conch shell is still used fairly regularly in the Caribbean by fishermen and farmers and as part of carnivals and festivals.

As Jeremy Montagu says in his historical survey of conch shell trumpets: “The Conch can claim to be one of humanity’s first trumpets or horns, perhaps indeed the first, for one has been found in one of France’s caves from the Upper Paleolithic period dating back some 20,000 years.” [8].

In 2021 a conch shell in in the Museum de Toulouse collection was in fact confirmed to be 17,000 years old. Three notes were able to be played by one of the scientists, who also happened to be a skilled horn player; C, D and C sharp. There are plans for it to be played in the cave from which it originated; archaeologist Gilles Tosello speculates that it will be “…a moment of great emotion”. [9]

We can only speculate on Cragen Beca’s provenance. The rich stories of its long history spiral and accrete around it.

How this evocative object arrived in west Wales ultimately remains a mystery. We know that it is at least 180 years old, and perhaps far older. We also know that it spent a century or more hidden away in a locked cabinet, too dangerous to be spoken of aloud.

Cragen Beca’s possible connection to the slave trade, however direct or remote, perhaps brings an even deeper resonance to its later incarnation at the lip of Rebecca’s ‘whipper-up’. Dr Martin Luther King Jr reasoned in his 1968 address that “…a riot is the language of the unheard”. [10] He was reflecting on the impoverished societal conditions and persistent lack of justice for black Americans. Despite his strong stance of non-violence, he understood that ‘violent rebellions’ are often the only form of language left available to the oppressed.

At the time of writing, we are living through the aftermath of the death of George Floyd at the hands of white policemen in Minneapolis. Protests have been staged across the globe; we are listening and engaging with the voices of the Black Lives Matter movement and have witnessed the toppling of slave trader, Edward Colston’s statue in Bristol. Lt Gen Thomas Picton’s memorial in Carmarthen town is another public monument under scrutiny because of the documented brutality of Picton’s rule as Governor of Trinidad (1797 – 1803). On 8th July 2020, Carmarthenshire County Council committed to review the appropriateness of Picton’s memorial in the 21st Century; on July 18th there was a ‘Picton must fall’ protest march from Guildhall Square to the monument. Within the small fenced garden that encloses Picton’s memorial, standing in uneasy juxtaposition, is a blue plaque commemorating Rebecca’s 1843 procession into Carmarthen from the Plough and Harrow alongside the people of Talog.

Perhaps then Cragen Beca is, for this corner of Wales, a mouthpiece for that reverberating “hoot”’ of centuries of protest in its many forms. A complex and imaginative symbol for the contemporary people of Carmarthenshire that speaks of justice, freedom, strength and resilience.

Kathryn Campbell 2020

 [1] Black and British: A Forgotten History, David Olusoga, Pan Books, London, 2017, pp. 319 – 320

[2] DIED. On Saturday last, aged 37, Lieut. William Williams formerly of Machynlleth in North Wales, and late of the Brazillian Naval Service off the coast of Africa. In his earthly pilgrimage he lived the life of a free citizen and a true hearted sailor; and it may not be uninstructive for the world to know, or unacceptable for his few friends and lamenting relatives, to witness this tribute of affectionate remembrance in recording it, – that in his short career, chequered like the ocean he had traversed with alternate sunshine and storm, he uniformly and unobtrusively practiced within his narrow span of action, the unpretending and inherited qualities of “peace, charity and goodwill.” their genial influence solaced his last moments, so that nothing in his life became him like the ending of it. He died the fervid confiding Christian; like a weary traveler he sank to eternal rest in speechless devotion, in dying faith, and communion with God. Peace to his gentle spirit! A gratifying and lasting consolation yet survives, that in the sanctity of attachment that embalms the memory of departed friendship, human affection appears to approach the immortality for which it was designed. His remains were consigned to the tomb at St. Ishmael’s, Carmarthenshire, within the sound of that element to which he had in early life been wedded, and to which he had devoted a light-hearted and fleeting existence.

The Cambrian, p.3, 18 February 1832.

[3] TALOG. The Election. – A great meeting in support of Mr John Hinds, the Liberal candidate for West Carmarthenshire, was held at Bethania Chapel, Talog, on Tuesday night. On the approach of the motor car being seen in the distance, the historic horn of Rebecca Riots fame was sounded, and afterwards a torchlight procession was formed. The Chairman of the meeting was Mr David Griffiths, Glasfryn, who briefly opened the proceedings, and then called on Mr Hinds to address the audience. Mr Hinds, in a telling speech, which was delivered with great earnestness, greatly denounced the power of the Lords, and hoped this block against freedom and justice would soon be removed. Thereby the great Welsh Bill now in hand would soon become law. Mr Hinds was followed by Mr Huws Davies, of London; Rev. D.G. Williams, St. clears; Rev. D. Talog Griffiths. A vote of confidence in Mr Hinds was proposed by the Rev. J. Lewis, Blaencoed, and carried unanimously.

The Welshman, p.8,  9 December 1910

[4] Carmarthen Town Council

[5] Liberal Government and Politics, 1905 – 15, Ian Packer, Palgrave Macmillan, New York, 2006, p.108

[6] The Art Journal, pp. 52 – 54, Marine Contributions to Art, Virtue & Co, London, 1874

[7] Endangered animal parts seized in Pembrokeshire boat raid, BBC News,18 June 2020

[8] The Conch Horn: Shell Trumpets of the World from Prehistory to Today, Jeremy Montagu, Hataf Segol Publications, 2018, p.1 (introduction)

[9] Conch shell in French museum found to be 17,000-year-old wind instrument, Esther Addley, The Guardian, 10 February 2021

[10] The Other America, Speech by Rev. Martin Luther King, Jr. Grosse Pointe High School, 14 March 1968


The Rebecca Riots: A study in agrarian discontent, David Williams, University of Wales Press, Cardiff, 1986

Rebecca’s Children: A study of rural society, crime, and protest, David J.V. Jones, Clarendon Press, Oxford 1989

Rebecca Riots! The True Tales of the Transvestite Terrorists who Vexed Victoria, Henry Tobit Evans (1844-1908) @ David M. Goss 2010

Petticoat Heroes: Gender, Culture and Popular Protest in the Rebecca Riots, Rhian E. Jones, University of Wales Press, Cardiff, 2015

And they blessed Rebecca: An account of the Welsh Toll-gate Riots 1839-1844, Pat a Malloy, Gomer Press, Llandysul, 1983

Welsh Folk Customs, Trevor M. Owen, Gomer Press, Llandysul, 1994

Customs in Common: Studies in Traditional Popular Culture, E.P. Thompson, Rough Music p. 467 – 531, The New Press, New York, 1993

The Conch Horn: Shell Trumpets of the World from Prehistory to Today, Jeremy Montagu, Hataf Segol Publications, 2018

Shells as Evidence of the Migrations of Early Culture, Wilfred Jackson, Manchester University Press, Manchester, 1917); p. 33–69.

Slave Wales: The Welsh and Atlantic Slavery 1660-1850, Chris Evans, University of Wales Press, Cardiff, 2010

Our Mother’s Land: Chapters in Welsh Women’s History 1830-1939, Ed. Angela V. John, University of Wales Press, Cardiff, 1991

The Naval Miscellany Vol Vlll, Ed. Brian Vale, Routledge, London & New York, 2017

Britannia’s Dragon: A Naval History of Wales, J.D.Davies, The History Press Ltd, 2013

The Sailors’ Graves, J.D. Davies – Historian and Author, 7 March 2012

Navies in Modern World History, Laurence Sondhaus, Shaping the Southern Colossus: The Brazilian Navy, 1822 – 31, p.78 – 105, Reaktion Books, London, 2004

Thanks to Jeremy Montagu who was kind enough to discuss and share his knowledge and expertise on the subject of the Conch Trumpet. Jeremy was ex-curator of the Bate Collection of Musical Instruments and lecturer in the University of Oxford (1981-95), Faculty of Music; collector and international advisor to museums and arts bodies; Fellow of the Society of Antiquaries and President of the Galpin Society (the major international society for the study of musical instruments).

%d bloggers like this: